One More Than Beethoven: Schubert’s Octet

Wilhelm August Rieder: Franz Schubert (1825) (watercolour)

Wilhelm August Rieder: Franz Schubert (1825) (watercolour)

Count Ferdinand Troyer (1780-1851) occupied a position of power as chief steward to Archduke Rudolf of Austria and also as an amateur clarinettist. His performance of the clarinet obliggato in ‘Parto, parto’ from Mozart’s La Clemenza di Tito with the Vienna Philharmonic Society in March 1817 drew positive notices for his ‘extremely tender handling’ of the clarinet. He became a renowned clarinettist and in 1824, commissioned Franz Schubert to write a companion piece to Beethoven’s Septet in E flat major, op 20.

Johann Baptist von Lampi the Elder:  Archduke Rudolph of Austria (Vienna Museum)

Johann Baptist von Lampi the Elder: Archduke Rudolph of Austria (Vienna Museum)

Archduke Rudolph had been a long-time support of the arts and had been an important patron of Beethoven’s, being the ‘Archduke’ of the Archduke Trio.

Beethoven’s Septet of 1802 was written for a mixed wind and string ensemble of clarinet, horn, bassoon, violin, viola, cello, and double bass. Beethoven’s work was innovative for the time, not only for its scoring of a single clarinet, horn, and bassoon, which were usually written for as pairs, but also for his clarinet writing, making its lines as important as those of the violin.

Schubert accepted Troyer’s commission and used the same instrumentation with the addition of a second violin. The work was innovative for Schubert in that it was largest chamber ensemble he’d written for. The work received its premiere at the home of Archduke Rudolf and included many of the musicians who’d performed the premiere of Beethoven’s Septet.

The work has six movements, and the first movement uses a theme from Schubert’s song Der Wanderer, D. 493. Schubert modelled his Octet closely on Beethoven’s Septet, including the structure of the movements and the keys used. The first movement opens with a slow Adagio before a spirited Allegro speeds things up.

Franz Schubert: Octet in F major, D. 803 – I. Adagio – Allegro – Più allegro

This performance was recorded in 1959 for a radio concert. The performers include the Trio Pasquier (Jean (violin), Pierre (viola), and Ètienne (cello)) with Jacques Lancelot on clarinet, Paul Hongne on bassoon, and André Gantiez on horn. The Octet is filled out by Madeleine Thuillier, violin, and Henri Moreau, double bass.

One More Than Beethoven: Schubert’s OctetPerformed by

Trio Pasquier
Madeleine Thuillier
Henri Moreau
Jacques Lancelot
Paul Hongne
André Gantiez

Recorded in 1959

Official Website

For more of the best in classical music, sign up to our E-Newsletter

You May Also Enjoy


  1. The genius of Schubert is such that even when he’s consciously copying and modeling his work to another composer, and even more a specific work, he cannot HELP but still be so original. With so many of his late works, what makes them so amazing is not just their amazing expressions and beauty of those expressions, but that they are TOTALLY unprecedented in their construction and nature of discourse. The performance here leaves much to be desired, but the beauty of the music still comes through, and in its many imperfections (the poor horn player…) it sounds very fresh. The sound quality is strangely satisfactory, with the sense of the space it was recorded in being felt.

  2. An absolutely amazing site.. so much material, and everything so professionally presented.. thankyou, ‘Interlude’..!

Leave a Comment

All fields are required. Your email address will not be published.